Menu
  • Locations
  • WTS Global
  • Culture & Career
  • Our Experts
  • Our Services
  • News
  • Knowledge
  • Locations
  • Search
  • Press
  • Events & Webinars
  • Contact
  • Member Login
  • CI Guide
  • Albania
  • Angola
  • Argentina
  • Armenia
  • Australia
  • Austria
  • Bangladesh
  • Belarus
  • Belgium
  • Benin
  • Bolivia
  • Brazil
  • Bulgaria
  • Burkina Faso
  • Burundi
  • Cambodia
  • Cameroon
  • Canada
  • Chile
  • China
  • Colombia
  • Costa Rica
  • Croatia
  • Cyprus
  • Czech Republic
  • Denmark
  • Dominican Republic
  • Ecuador
  • Egypt
  • El Salvador
  • Estonia
  • Finland
  • France
  • Georgia
  • Germany
  • Ghana
  • Gibraltar
  • Greece
  • Guatemala
  • Guinea
  • Honduras
  • Hong Kong
  • Hungary
  • Iceland
  • India
  • Indonesia
  • Iran
  • Iraq
  • Ireland
  • Israel
  • Italy
  • Ivory Coast
  • Japan
  • Kazakhstan
  • Kenya
  • Korea
  • Kyrgyzstan
  • Laos
  • Latvia
  • Lithuania
  • Luxembourg
  • Macao
  • Macedonia
  • Madagascar
  • Malaysia
  • Mali
  • Malta
  • Mauritius
  • Mexico
  • Moldova
  • Mongolia
  • Montenegro
  • Morocco
  • Mozambique
  • Myanmar
  • Nepal
  • Netherlands
  • New Zealand
  • Nicaragua
  • Niger
  • Nigeria
  • Norway
  • Pakistan
  • Panama
  • Paraguay
  • Peru
  • Philippines
  • Poland
  • Portugal
  • Puerto Rico
  • Romania
  • Russia
  • Rwanda
  • Saudi Arabia
  • Senegal
  • Serbia
  • Singapore
  • Slovakia
  • Slovenia
  • South Africa
  • Spain
  • Sri Lanka
  • Sweden
  • Switzerland
  • Taiwan
  • Tanzania
  • Thailand
  • Togo
  • Trinidad and Tobago
  • Tunisia
  • Turkey
  • Turkmenistan
  • Uganda
  • Ukraine
  • United Arab Emirates
  • United Kingdom
  • Uruguay
  • USA
  • Uzbekistan
  • Venezuela
  • Vietnam
  • Zambia
  • About Us
  • Our CEO
  • Our Board
  • Quality, Process & Risk Management
  • Culture and Leadership
  • Diversity
  • WTS Global Academy
  • Career
  • Your Development
  • Corporate Tax
  • Customs
  • Global Mobility
  • Indirect Tax
  • International Corporate Tax
  • Mergers & Acquisitions (M&A)
  • Private Clients & Family Office Services
  • Real Estate Services
  • Tax Controversy
  • Tax Technology
  • Transfer Pricing & Valuation Services
  • Latest News
  • Brochures
  • Newsletters
  • Surveys & Studies
  • Subscription
  • COVID-19 Global updates
  • The Digital Tax Law Center (DTLC)
  • VAT Update for the Digital Economy
  • The European Tax Law Center (ETLC)
  • OECD Proposal for a new tax order - Comments
  • Tax Loss Carryback
  • Real Estate Guide
  • success
  • error
  • termination
  • registration-success
  • Press
  • Events & Webinars
  • Contact
  • Member Login
  • CI Guide
WTS worldwide
  • Albania
  • Angola
  • Argentina
  • Armenia
  • Australia
  • Austria
  • Bangladesh
  • Belarus
  • Belgium
  • Benin
  • Bolivia
  • Brazil
  • Bulgaria
  • Burkina Faso
  • Burundi
  • Cambodia
  • Cameroon
  • Canada
  • Chile
  • China
  • Colombia
  • Costa Rica
  • Croatia
  • Cyprus
  • Czech Republic
  • Denmark
  • Dominican Republic
  • Ecuador
  • Egypt
  • El Salvador
  • Estonia
  • Finland
  • France
  • Georgia
  • Germany
  • Ghana
  • Gibraltar
  • Greece
  • Guatemala
  • Guinea
  • Honduras
  • Hong Kong
  • Hungary
  • Iceland
  • India
  • Indonesia
  • Iran
  • Iraq
  • Ireland
  • Israel
  • Italy
  • Ivory Coast
  • Japan
  • Kazakhstan
  • Kenya
  • Korea
  • Kyrgyzstan
  • Laos
  • Latvia
  • Lithuania
  • Luxembourg
  • Macao
  • Macedonia
  • Madagascar
  • Malaysia
  • Mali
  • Malta
  • Mauritius
  • Mexico
  • Moldova
  • Mongolia
  • Montenegro
  • Morocco
  • Mozambique
  • Myanmar
  • Nepal
  • Netherlands
  • New Zealand
  • Nicaragua
  • Niger
  • Nigeria
  • Norway
  • Pakistan
  • Panama
  • Paraguay
  • Peru
  • Philippines
  • Poland
  • Portugal
  • Puerto Rico
  • Romania
  • Russia
  • Rwanda
  • Saudi Arabia
  • Senegal
  • Serbia
  • Singapore
  • Slovakia
  • Slovenia
  • South Africa
  • Spain
  • Sri Lanka
  • Sweden
  • Switzerland
  • Taiwan
  • Tanzania
  • Thailand
  • Togo
  • Trinidad and Tobago
  • Tunisia
  • Turkey
  • Turkmenistan
  • Uganda
  • Ukraine
  • United Arab Emirates
  • United Kingdom
  • Uruguay
  • USA
  • Uzbekistan
  • Venezuela
  • Vietnam
  • Zambia
  • WTS Global
    WTS Global

    Here you will find more information on our organization’s structure, experts and global reach.

    Read more
    About Us Our CEO Our Board Quality, Process & Risk Management
  • Culture & Career
    Culture & Career

    The WTS Global Academy - Bringing value to the whole

    Read more
    Culture and Leadership Diversity WTS Global Academy Career Your Development
  • Our Experts
    Our Experts

    With a representation in over 100 countries, our team offers local expertise on a global scale. Learn more about our experts.

    Read more
  • Our Services
    Our Services

    Through our global network firms we deliver practical and individualized solutions in all areas of tax. Learn more about our global services.

    Read more
    Corporate Tax Customs Global Mobility Indirect Tax International Corporate Tax
    Mergers & Acquisitions (M&A) Private Clients & Family Office Services Real Estate Services Tax Controversy Tax Technology
    Transfer Pricing & Valuation Services
  • News
    News

    Find here the latest tax news for our locations worldwide.

    Read more
    Latest News
  • Knowledge
    Knowledge

    Our quick overview with downloads: newsletters, publications, surveys. 

    Read more
    Brochures Newsletters Surveys & Studies Subscription COVID-19 Global updates
    The Digital Tax Law Center (DTLC) VAT Update for the Digital Economy The European Tax Law Center (ETLC) OECD Proposal for a new tax order - Comments Tax Loss Carryback
    Real Estate Guide
  • Locations
    Locations

    Our locations worldwide

    Read more
  • Search
Home Arm’s Length Range – Recent Case Laws
22.06.2020

Arm’s Length Range – Recent Case Laws

Author
Franco Pozzi
Partner
Italy | SBN
View Profile

On 14 May 2018, the Ministry of Finance issued transfer pricing guidelines consistent with “international best practices” (hereinafter the “Decree”) in accordance with the new principles introduced by BEPS project – Actions 8-10, OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Administrations in the version issued in 2017 (“2017 OECD Guidelines”).

Article 6 of the Decree provides that the entire range obtained from the selected profit level indicator (“PLI”) is acceptable as compliant with the arm’s length principle, as stated in paragraph 3.62 of the OECD guidelines: “where the range comprises results of relatively equal and high reliability, it could be argued that any point in the range satisfies the arm’s length principle”. More precisely, the Decree refers to a “homogeneous” level of reliability.

In spite of this, the entire range is applicable only in case of “perfect” comparability among uncontrolled and controlled transactions. Such an approach will require further clarification with regard to the “perfect” comparability and a circular letter from tax administration is long awaited by Italian taxpayers, together with additional instruction concerning the use of databases, choice of geographic market of reference, period(s) to be used for the analysis, possible inclusion of loss-making companies, dimension of comparables and comparability adjustments.

As mentioned in Article 3 of the Decree, an independent transaction is considered comparable to a controlled transaction when:

  • there are no material differences that significantly affect the profit level indicator that can be used in application of the most appropriate TP method;
  • where differences emerge, such differences can be eliminated or materially reduced through comparability adjustments.

For these purposes, comparability adjustments (e.g. working capital adjustment aimed at reducing/eliminating different levels of account receivables, account payables and inventory between the tested party and the comparable companies) seem to be legitimated.

The notion of comparability therefore reflects the “economically relevant characteristics” or “comparability factors” as set forth in the 2017 OECD Guidelines.

The abovementioned application of the full range of the benchmark has been recently applied in various Tax Courts’ decisions also for litigations concerning fiscal years that closed before the issue of the Decree.

The Provincial Tax Court of Milan was one of the first to mention the Decree. In fact, decision no. 5445/2018 has held that each value included in the range (including minimum and maximum) must be considered compliant with the arm’s length principle, and has rejected adjustments to the median proposed by the Tax Authorities.

The mentioned decision is consistent with two other judgments of particular interest: no. 188/13/20 issued by the Provincial Tax Court of Milan and no. 5005/19/18 of the Regional Tax Court of Milan.

The first assessment took place considering a “segregation” between the various business lines of the Italian company, and it was focused on the arm’s length remuneration of the distribution activity tested through the application of the TNMM, where ROS was considered as the proper PLI. Said approach can be considered in line with the best domestic and international practice. Thus, tax inspectors also included in the ROS result some severance incurred by the Italian company (and attributable to the distribution activity) deriving from workforce restructuring with a reduction of the related personnel; in addition, the benchmark analysis proposed by the taxpayer was not accepted. The outcome of the tax audit was a TP adjustment on the median of the relevant benchmark.

Under the described scenario, the Tax Court did not deal with the inclusion of the severance costs in the company’s ROS (that under the best practice should be considered as an extraordinary item of income in order to establish the consistency of the TP policy applied), but it rejected the TP adjustment since the actual ROS realised through the distribution business was included in the full range of the benchmark, considering outliers observations as well as re-determined by the same tax administration.

The second case, no. 5005/19/18, is related to the activities performed by the taxpayer that were limited to tool manufacturing and limited risk distribution. The judges considered that each point in the interquartile range, also below the average value, was representative of the arm’s length value due to functions, risks and intangibles.

Notwithstanding the above described Tax Court decisions, under common practice the benchmark range considered as consistent with the arm’s length principle should be included between the lower and the upper interquartile, where minimum and maximum observations can be acceptable should specific circumstances be verified.

Article published in TP Newsletter 1/2020

With this newsletter, we inform multinational companies on country-specific and international legislative documents and regulations.

Subscribe now
Newsletter Transfer Pricing
Transfer Pricing Newsletter: Update on the recent news and cases in 14 countries as well as an OECD update on Pillar 1
View publication
Articles you might be interested in

Services supplied by datacenters should not qualify as services related to real property. For an overview of the recent developments relating to the vat qualification of services provided by data centers, please see our latest updates.

Services provided by datacenters are not services relating to real property
read more

On 29 October 2020, China’s State Administration of Taxation released the “2019 Advanced Pricing Arrangement Annual Report” (2019 APA report).

China publishes annual APA report
read more

Budget 2021 was delivered on 16 February 2021 and signals a shift from containing COVID-19 to restructuring and preparing Singapore’s economy and workforce for the post-pandemic world.

Singapore Budget 2021 - Emerging Stronger Together
read more

Get in contact

If you have any questions about WTS Global or our global services, please get in touch.
We will respond to you as soon as possible.

Contact
About Us
  • WTS Global
  • Our CEO
  • Our Board
  • Quality, Process & Risk Management
Culture & Career
  • Culture and Leadership
  • Diversity
  • Career
  • Your Development
Our Services
  • Corporate Tax
  • Customs
  • Global Mobility
  • Indirect Tax
  • International Corporate Tax
  • Mergers & Acquisitions (M&A)
  • Private Clients & Family Office Services
  • Real Estate Services
  • Tax Controversy
  • Tax Technology
  • Transfer Pricing & Valuation Services
News
  • COVID-19 Global updates
  • The European Tax Law Center (ETLC)
  • VAT Update for the Digital Economy
  • OECD Proposal for a new tax order - Comments
  • Study: Artificial Intelligence within taxation
  • Study: WTS Global Country TP Guide
Knowledge
  • Subscription
  • ITP Newsletter
  • Global Mobility Newsletter
  • VAT Newsletter
  • Transfer Pricing Newsletter
  • Private Clients & Family Office Services
  • Brochures
  • Tax Loss Carryback
Exclusive Cooperation With
© 2021 WTS Company Information Data Protection Disclaimer