Menu
  • Locations
  • About Us
  • Services
  • Experts
  • News
  • Knowledge
  • Culture & Career
  • Locations
  • Search
  • Press
  • Events & Webinars
  • CI Guide
  • Contact
  • Albania
  • Angola
  • Argentina
  • Armenia
  • Australia
  • Austria
  • Bangladesh
  • Belarus
  • Belgium
  • Benin
  • Bolivia
  • Bosnia & Herzegovina
  • Brazil
  • Bulgaria
  • Burkina Faso
  • Burundi
  • Cambodia
  • Cameroon
  • Canada
  • Chile
  • China
  • Colombia
  • Costa Rica
  • Croatia
  • Cyprus
  • Czech Republic
  • Denmark
  • Dominican Republic
  • Ecuador
  • Egypt
  • El Salvador
  • Estonia
  • Finland
  • France
  • Georgia
  • Germany
  • Ghana
  • Gibraltar
  • Greece
  • Guatemala
  • Guinea
  • Honduras
  • Hong Kong
  • Hungary
  • Iceland
  • India
  • Indonesia
  • Iran
  • Iraq
  • Ireland
  • Israel
  • Italy
  • Ivory Coast
  • Japan
  • Kazakhstan
  • Kenya
  • Korea
  • Kyrgyzstan
  • Laos
  • Latvia
  • Lithuania
  • Luxembourg
  • Macao
  • Macedonia
  • Madagascar
  • Malaysia
  • Mali
  • Malta
  • Mauritius
  • Mexico
  • Moldova
  • Mongolia
  • Montenegro
  • Morocco
  • Mozambique
  • Myanmar
  • Nepal
  • Netherlands
  • New Zealand
  • Niger
  • Nigeria
  • Norway
  • Pakistan
  • Panama
  • Paraguay
  • Peru
  • Philippines
  • Poland
  • Portugal
  • Puerto Rico
  • Romania
  • Russia
  • Rwanda
  • Saudi Arabia
  • Senegal
  • Serbia
  • Seychelles
  • Singapore
  • Slovakia
  • Slovenia
  • South Africa
  • Spain
  • Sri Lanka
  • Sweden
  • Switzerland
  • Taiwan
  • Tanzania
  • Thailand
  • Togo
  • Trinidad and Tobago
  • Tunisia
  • Turkey
  • Turkmenistan
  • Uganda
  • Ukraine
  • United Arab Emirates
  • United Kingdom
  • Uruguay
  • USA
  • Uzbekistan
  • Venezuela
  • Vietnam
  • Zambia
  • About Us
  • Our CEO
  • Our Board
  • Our Global Executive Team
  • Quality, Process & Risk Management
  • Corporate Tax
  • Customs
  • Financial Services
  • Global Mobility
  • Indirect Tax
  • International Corporate Tax
  • Mergers & Acquisitions (M&A)
  • Private Clients & Family Office
  • Sustainability & ESG in Taxation
  • Tax Controversy
  • Tax Technology
  • Transfer Pricing & Valuation
  • Real Estate
  • Latest News
  • Pillar Two - Global Minimum Tax
  • Brochures
  • Newsletters
  • Newsletter Subscription
  • Surveys & Studies
  • The Digital Tax Law Center (DTLC)
  • The European Tax Law Center (ETLC)
  • Climate Protection, Green Tax & Energy
  • Sustainability & ESG in Taxation
  • Tax Loss Carryback
  • Real Estate Guide
  • Tax and Investment Facts CEE
  • Assignments to Europe & Asia Pacific
  • Assignments to the Americas
  • Culture and Leadership
  • Diversity
  • WTS Global Academy
  • Career
  • Your Development
  • Jobs
  • Pillar Two Team
  • Press
  • Events & Webinars
  • CI Guide
  • Contact
WTS worldwide
  • Albania
  • Angola
  • Argentina
  • Armenia
  • Australia
  • Austria
  • Bangladesh
  • Belarus
  • Belgium
  • Benin
  • Bolivia
  • Bosnia & Herzegovina
  • Brazil
  • Bulgaria
  • Burkina Faso
  • Burundi
  • Cambodia
  • Cameroon
  • Canada
  • Chile
  • China
  • Colombia
  • Costa Rica
  • Croatia
  • Cyprus
  • Czech Republic
  • Denmark
  • Dominican Republic
  • Ecuador
  • Egypt
  • El Salvador
  • Estonia
  • Finland
  • France
  • Georgia
  • Germany
  • Ghana
  • Gibraltar
  • Greece
  • Guatemala
  • Guinea
  • Honduras
  • Hong Kong
  • Hungary
  • Iceland
  • India
  • Indonesia
  • Iran
  • Iraq
  • Ireland
  • Israel
  • Italy
  • Ivory Coast
  • Japan
  • Kazakhstan
  • Kenya
  • Korea
  • Kyrgyzstan
  • Laos
  • Latvia
  • Lithuania
  • Luxembourg
  • Macao
  • Macedonia
  • Madagascar
  • Malaysia
  • Mali
  • Malta
  • Mauritius
  • Mexico
  • Moldova
  • Mongolia
  • Montenegro
  • Morocco
  • Mozambique
  • Myanmar
  • Nepal
  • Netherlands
  • New Zealand
  • Niger
  • Nigeria
  • Norway
  • Pakistan
  • Panama
  • Paraguay
  • Peru
  • Philippines
  • Poland
  • Portugal
  • Puerto Rico
  • Romania
  • Russia
  • Rwanda
  • Saudi Arabia
  • Senegal
  • Serbia
  • Singapore
  • Slovakia
  • Slovenia
  • South Africa
  • Spain
  • Sri Lanka
  • Sweden
  • Switzerland
  • Taiwan
  • Tanzania
  • Thailand
  • Togo
  • Trinidad and Tobago
  • Tunisia
  • Turkey
  • Turkmenistan
  • Uganda
  • Ukraine
  • United Arab Emirates
  • United Kingdom
  • Uruguay
  • USA
  • Uzbekistan
  • Venezuela
  • Vietnam
  • Zambia
  • About Us
    About Us

    Here you will find more information on our organization’s structure, experts and global reach.

    Read more
    About Us Our CEO Our Board Our Global Executive Team Quality, Process & Risk Management
  • Services
    Services
    Read more
    Corporate Tax Customs Financial Services Global Mobility Indirect Tax
    International Corporate Tax Mergers & Acquisitions (M&A) Private Clients & Family Office Sustainability & ESG in Taxation Tax Controversy
    Tax Technology Transfer Pricing & Valuation Real Estate
  • Experts
    Experts

    With a representation in over 100 countries, our team offers local expertise on a global scale. Learn more about our experts.

    Read more
  • News
    News

    Find here the latest news 

    Read more
    Latest News
  • Knowledge
    Knowledge
    Read more
    Pillar Two - Global Minimum Tax Brochures Newsletters Newsletter Subscription Surveys & Studies
    The Digital Tax Law Center (DTLC) The European Tax Law Center (ETLC) Climate Protection, Green Tax & Energy Sustainability & ESG in Taxation Tax Loss Carryback
    Real Estate Guide Tax and Investment Facts CEE Assignments to Europe & Asia Pacific Assignments to the Americas
  • Culture & Career
    Culture & Career

    The WTS Global Academy - Bringing value to the whole

    Read more
    Culture and Leadership Diversity WTS Global Academy Career Your Development
    Jobs
  • Locations
    Locations
    Read more
  • Search
21.11.2022

Tax court rules on PE under Belgium-Argentina tax treaty

Author
Cristian E. Rosso Alba
Managing Partner
WTS Global Transfer Pricing LATAM Regional Leader
Argentina
View Profile

20 May 2022 saw the Argentine Tax Court (“ATC”) rule in the case “Solvay Indupa SAIC s/apelación – Impuesto a las Ganancias” as to whether a Belgium company should be regarded as having an Argentine PE in view of the “work site” and “service PE” stan­dards. The case was entered for the taxpayer, considering that the time threshold was not met, while the work site PE issue was a controversy in financial years different to the ones under assessment.

The Argentine Revenue Service (“ARS”) considered that the Belgium Company Solvay S.A. (“Solvay”) had a PE in the country during the years 2001 to 2006, in which it provid­ed technical assistance to its Argentine affiliate, “Indupa”. Interestingly, the ARS blamed the latter -namely the Argentine payer -for not acting as a domestic with­holding agent that had made payments to an unregistered taxpayer.

The tax assessment was based on two different activities carried out by Solvay in Argentina, namely: (i) the execution of a construction work destined to expand a production plant in Bahia Blanca, Argentina, owned by the Argentine-affiliated compa­ny Indupa. To perform such work, an unrelated construction company was hired in Argentina, for a term beyond two years, which took place before the years under assessment; and (ii) the provision of the advisory and technical assistance services required for the maintenance of the quality of the production of such plant.

The ATC took the side of the taxpayer. In its ruling, the ATC considered the provisions of the Double Tax Treaty between Argentina and Belgium (“DTT”). Indeed, from the evidence produced in the case, the ATC deemed that it was properly proven that the construction was actually carried out by an Argentine subcontractor (i.e. Techint S.A.), and not by Solvay, during the financial years excluded from the notice of deficiency. Accordingly, the ATC ruled that this fact may not be reasonably introduced in a differ­ent financial period. Also, regarding the advisory and technical assistance services, it was proven that the employees of Solvay stayed in Argentina for only 58 days per year, on average, which was well below the minimum physical presence threshold required by the DTT (i.e. a period of six months within any twelve-month period). Consequently, the ATC understood that none of the two factors mentioned by the ARS was adequate to determine the existence of a PE of Solvay in Argentina, and therefore it ruled in favour of the company.

The ATC also made clear that the recently broader PE standards, introduced by the 2018 tax reform, may not be used to frame this controversy, as the financial years in controversy well preceded such tax reform.

It should be noted that the reform broadens the Argentine PE definition, following OECD-BEPS Action 7 standards. These standards resulted in a new income tax provi­sion (Section 22), which is quite broad (i.e. includes any in-country person, working on behalf of a non-resident, who assumed risks that are attributable to the latter, among others). Such income tax provision has been challenged by local tax scholars for being inconsistent with many double tax treaties already executed by Argentina (like the Belgium-Argentina one). While such a controversy has not been present in the Solvay case, scholars’ expectations are that – in view of the higher priority of treaty law vis-à-vis domestic legislation – domestic income tax standards may not alter the treaty law outcome, to the extent that they are clearly incompatible.

Read the WTS Global International Corporate Tax Newsletter here.

Author
Cristian E. Rosso Alba
Managing Partner
WTS Global Transfer Pricing LATAM Regional Leader
Argentina
View Profile
Article published in WTS Global ICT Newsletter #2/2022
Changes in international tax law and country-specific tax law developments with respect to cross-border transactions
View publication
Newsletter International Corporate Tax

With this newsletter, we inform multinational companies on changes in international tax law and country-specific tax law developments with respect to cross-border transactions.

Subscribe now
Articles you might be interested in

The tax framework for leasing transactions – included in Decree No. 1038/2000 (“DL”), as amended – has recently been modified. 

Argentina: Financial Lease Transactions: Changes in the Tax Framework
Read more

The Argentine Income Tax law includes a large number of “deemed affiliated” companies. All of them must be scrutinized in the annual Transfer Pricing report, which needs to be filed mandatorily with the Argentine Revenue Service.

Argentina: Deemed Affiliation - Cross-Border Transactions with Low-Tax Jurisdictions
Read more

Get in contact

If you have any questions about WTS Global or our global services, please get in touch.
We will respond to you as soon as possible.

Contact
About Us
  • About Us
  • Our CEO
  • Our Board
  • Our Global Executive Team
  • Quality, Process & Risk Management
Services
  • Corporate Tax
  • Customs
  • Financial Services
  • Global Mobility
  • Indirect Tax
  • International Corporate Tax
  • Mergers & Acquisitions (M&A)
  • Private Clients & Family Office
  • Sustainability & ESG in Taxation
  • Tax Controversy
  • Tax Technology
  • Transfer Pricing & Valuation
News
Knowledge
  • Pillar Two - Global Minimum Tax
  • Brochures
  • Newsletters
  • Surveys & Studies
  • The Digital Tax Law Center (DTLC)
  • VAT Update for the Digital Economy
  • The European Tax Law Center (ETLC)
  • Tax Loss Carryback
  • Real Estate Guide
Culture & Career
  • Culture and Leadership
  • Diversity
  • WTS Global Academy
  • Career
  • Your Development
  • Jobs
Exclusive Cooperation With
© 2023 WTS Company Information Data Protection Disclaimer