Menu
  • Locations
  • About Us
  • Services
  • Experts
  • News
  • Knowledge
  • Culture & Career
  • Locations
  • Search
  • Press
  • Events & Webinars
  • Contact
  • Albania
  • Angola
  • Argentina
  • Armenia
  • Australia
  • Austria
  • Bangladesh
  • Belarus
  • Belgium
  • Benin
  • Bolivia
  • Bosnia & Herzegovina
  • Brazil
  • Bulgaria
  • Burkina Faso
  • Burundi
  • Cambodia
  • Cameroon
  • Canada
  • Chile
  • China
  • Colombia
  • Costa Rica
  • Croatia
  • Cyprus
  • Czech Republic
  • Denmark
  • Dominican Republic
  • Ecuador
  • Egypt
  • El Salvador
  • Estonia
  • Finland
  • France
  • Georgia
  • Germany
  • Ghana
  • Gibraltar
  • Greece
  • Guatemala
  • Guinea
  • Honduras
  • Hong Kong
  • Hungary
  • Iceland
  • India
  • Indonesia
  • Iran
  • Iraq
  • Ireland
  • Israel
  • Italy
  • Ivory Coast
  • Japan
  • Kazakhstan
  • Kenya
  • Korea
  • Kyrgyzstan
  • Laos
  • Latvia
  • Lithuania
  • Luxembourg
  • Macao
  • Macedonia
  • Madagascar
  • Malaysia
  • Mali
  • Malta
  • Mauritius
  • Mexico
  • Moldova
  • Mongolia
  • Montenegro
  • Morocco
  • Mozambique
  • Myanmar
  • Nepal
  • Netherlands
  • New Zealand
  • Niger
  • Nigeria
  • Norway
  • Pakistan
  • Panama
  • Paraguay
  • Peru
  • Philippines
  • Poland
  • Portugal
  • Puerto Rico
  • Romania
  • Russia
  • Rwanda
  • Saudi Arabia
  • Senegal
  • Serbia
  • Seychelles
  • Singapore
  • Slovakia
  • Slovenia
  • South Africa
  • Spain
  • Sri Lanka
  • Sweden
  • Switzerland
  • Taiwan
  • Tanzania
  • Thailand
  • Togo
  • Trinidad and Tobago
  • Tunisia
  • Turkey
  • Turkmenistan
  • Uganda
  • Ukraine
  • United Arab Emirates
  • United Kingdom
  • Uruguay
  • USA
  • Uzbekistan
  • Venezuela
  • Vietnam
  • Zambia
  • About Us
  • Our CEO
  • Our Board
  • Our Global Executive Team
  • Quality, Process & Risk Management
  • Corporate Tax
  • Customs
  • Financial Services
  • Global Mobility
  • Indirect Tax
  • International Corporate Tax
  • Mergers & Acquisitions (M&A)
  • Private Clients & Family Office
  • Sustainability & ESG in Taxation
  • Tax Controversy
  • Tax Technology
  • Transfer Pricing & Valuation
  • Real Estate
  • Latest News
  • Pillar Two - Global Minimum Tax
  • Brochures
  • Newsletters
  • Newsletter Subscription
  • Surveys & Studies
  • The Digital Tax Law Center (DTLC)
  • The European Tax Law Center (ETLC)
  • Climate Protection, Green Tax & Energy
  • Sustainability & ESG in Taxation
  • Tax Loss Carryback
  • Real Estate Guide
  • Tax and Investment Facts CEE
  • Assignments to Europe & Asia Pacific
  • Assignments to the Americas
  • Culture and Leadership
  • Diversity
  • WTS Global Academy
  • Career
  • Your Development
  • Jobs
  • Pillar Two Team
  • Press
  • Events & Webinars
  • Contact
WTS worldwide
  • Albania
  • Angola
  • Argentina
  • Armenia
  • Australia
  • Austria
  • Bangladesh
  • Belarus
  • Belgium
  • Benin
  • Bolivia
  • Bosnia & Herzegovina
  • Brazil
  • Bulgaria
  • Burkina Faso
  • Burundi
  • Cambodia
  • Cameroon
  • Canada
  • Chile
  • China
  • Colombia
  • Costa Rica
  • Croatia
  • Cyprus
  • Czech Republic
  • Denmark
  • Dominican Republic
  • Ecuador
  • Egypt
  • El Salvador
  • Estonia
  • Finland
  • France
  • Georgia
  • Germany
  • Ghana
  • Gibraltar
  • Greece
  • Guatemala
  • Guinea
  • Honduras
  • Hong Kong
  • Hungary
  • Iceland
  • India
  • Indonesia
  • Iran
  • Iraq
  • Ireland
  • Israel
  • Italy
  • Ivory Coast
  • Japan
  • Kazakhstan
  • Kenya
  • Korea
  • Kyrgyzstan
  • Laos
  • Latvia
  • Lithuania
  • Luxembourg
  • Macao
  • Macedonia
  • Madagascar
  • Malaysia
  • Mali
  • Malta
  • Mauritius
  • Mexico
  • Moldova
  • Mongolia
  • Montenegro
  • Morocco
  • Mozambique
  • Myanmar
  • Nepal
  • Netherlands
  • New Zealand
  • Niger
  • Nigeria
  • Norway
  • Pakistan
  • Panama
  • Paraguay
  • Peru
  • Philippines
  • Poland
  • Portugal
  • Puerto Rico
  • Romania
  • Russia
  • Rwanda
  • Saudi Arabia
  • Senegal
  • Serbia
  • Singapore
  • Slovakia
  • Slovenia
  • South Africa
  • Spain
  • Sri Lanka
  • Sweden
  • Switzerland
  • Taiwan
  • Tanzania
  • Thailand
  • Togo
  • Trinidad and Tobago
  • Tunisia
  • Turkey
  • Turkmenistan
  • Uganda
  • Ukraine
  • United Arab Emirates
  • United Kingdom
  • Uruguay
  • USA
  • Uzbekistan
  • Venezuela
  • Vietnam
  • Zambia
  • About Us
    About Us

    Here you will find more information on our organization’s structure, experts and global reach.

    Read more
    About Us Our CEO Our Board Our Global Executive Team Quality, Process & Risk Management
  • Services
    Services
    Read more
    Corporate Tax Customs Financial Services Global Mobility Indirect Tax
    International Corporate Tax Mergers & Acquisitions (M&A) Private Clients & Family Office Sustainability & ESG in Taxation Tax Controversy
    Tax Technology Transfer Pricing & Valuation Real Estate
  • Experts
    Experts

    With a representation in over 100 countries, our team offers local expertise on a global scale. Learn more about our experts.

    Read more
  • News
    News

    Find here the latest news 

    Read more
    Latest News
  • Knowledge
    Knowledge
    Read more
    Pillar Two - Global Minimum Tax Brochures Newsletters Newsletter Subscription Surveys & Studies
    The Digital Tax Law Center (DTLC) The European Tax Law Center (ETLC) Climate Protection, Green Tax & Energy Sustainability & ESG in Taxation Tax Loss Carryback
    Real Estate Guide Tax and Investment Facts CEE Assignments to Europe & Asia Pacific Assignments to the Americas
  • Culture & Career
    Culture & Career

    The WTS Global Academy - Bringing value to the whole

    Read more
    Culture and Leadership Diversity WTS Global Academy Career Your Development
    Jobs
  • Locations
    Locations
    Read more
  • Search
21.11.2022

Double tax treaties: application of the double tax treaties and beneficial ownership CE, 20 May 2022, n° 444451 Sté Planet

Author
Laurent Leclercq
Managing Director/Partner
France | FIDAL, France
View Profile

In its decision, the French supreme tax court (Conseil d’Etat) had to decide whether, in the presence of intermediary companies, the treaty with the state of residence of the beneficial owner should be applied instead of the treaty with the state of the recipient of the payment.

In this case, the French company Planet paid royalties to Les Mills Belgium SPRL, a Belgian company, and to Les Mills Euromed Limited, a Maltese company, in consideration for the sub-distribution of collective fitness programmes developed by the company Les Mills International LTD, established in New Zealand. Originally, the sums were paid directly to the New Zealand company, which was the parent of the recipient companies.

These sums were subject to the withholding tax of Article 182 B of the French tax code by the tax authorities, reduced by the tax authorities to the rate of 10% provided for by the double tax treaty between France and New Zealand, in the belief that Les Mills International LTD was the true beneficial owner of these sums.

Planet contested this reasoning and considered that, on the contrary, the Franco-Bel­gian and Franco-Maltese double tax treaties should apply. This permitted the exemp­tion of the royalties paid to the Belgian entity from the French withholding tax on the basis of the DTT between France and Belgium.

The French supreme court, relying on the OECD commentaries on Article 12 of the OECD model double tax treaty, considers the provisions of Article 12(2) of the Fran­co-New Zealand tax treaty (which provides that “however, such royalties may also be taxed in the state in which they arise and according to the laws of that state, but if the person receiving the royalties is the beneficial owner, the tax so charged shall not exceed 10 per cent of the gross amount of the royalties”) are applicable to French source royalties whose beneficial owner resides in New Zealand, even if they have been paid to an intermediary established in a third country, provided that it is evi­denced that the NZ entity is the beneficial owner of these amounts. The mere fact taken into consideration by the Marseille administrative court of appeal that “the New Zealand company Les Mills International LTD should, pursuant to an agency agreement signed on 2 December 1998 between that company and the company Planet, be regarded as the actual beneficiary of the sums in dispute paid by the French company to the Belgian and Maltese companies” is not sufficient.

The French supreme court therefore refers the case back to the administrative court of appeal for retrial.

At this stage, the main impact of the decision is that the notion of beneficial owner effectively dictates the DTT to be applied subject to the wording of this treaty, provid­ed it is objectively evidenced, on the basis of the facts and circumstances of each case. In other words, the French tax authorities cannot just ignore the apparent situation and challenge the apparent recipient to sustain that only the French WHT would apply; in such a case, they must also have evidence as to who is the beneficial owner and apply the DTT based on this new factual situation.

Read the WTS Global International Corporate Tax Newsletter here.

Author
Laurent Leclercq
Managing Director/Partner
France | FIDAL, France
View Profile
Article published in WTS Global ICT Newsletter #2/2022
Changes in international tax law and country-specific tax law developments with respect to cross-border transactions
View publication
Newsletter International Corporate Tax

With this newsletter, we inform multinational companies on changes in international tax law and country-specific tax law developments with respect to cross-border transactions.

Subscribe now
Articles you might be interested in

Under the parent-subsidiary regime, dividends received by a parent company are exempt from corporate income tax (CIT)

French Supreme Tax Court validates the possibility of charging foreign tax credits on the share of costs and expenses on dividends
Read more

In principle, every employee recruited from abroad to take up a position in France is affiliat­ed to the compulsory French social security schemes for basic and supplementary retirement pension insurance.

French pension “impatriate” regime: exemption from affiliation and from payment of pension contributions
Read more

Recent case law regarding intercompany cash pool interest rates in a decision involving the SAP Group. 

France: The SAP Case - The Difficulty for Tax Courts when Handling Negative Interest Rates
Read more

Get in contact

If you have any questions about WTS Global or our global services, please get in touch.
We will respond to you as soon as possible.

Contact
About Us
  • About Us
  • Our CEO
  • Our Board
  • Our Global Executive Team
  • Quality, Process & Risk Management
Services
  • Corporate Tax
  • Customs
  • Financial Services
  • Global Mobility
  • Indirect Tax
  • International Corporate Tax
  • Mergers & Acquisitions (M&A)
  • Private Clients & Family Office
  • Sustainability & ESG in Taxation
  • Tax Controversy
  • Tax Technology
  • Transfer Pricing & Valuation
News
Knowledge
  • Pillar Two - Global Minimum Tax
  • Brochures
  • Newsletters
  • Surveys & Studies
  • The Digital Tax Law Center (DTLC)
  • VAT Update for the Digital Economy
  • The European Tax Law Center (ETLC)
  • Tax Loss Carryback
  • Real Estate Guide
Culture & Career
  • Culture and Leadership
  • Diversity
  • WTS Global Academy
  • Career
  • Your Development
  • Jobs
Exclusive Cooperation With
© 2023 WTS Company Information Data Protection Disclaimer